The usual method of tuning a guitar involves tuning
each high string by matching the pitch played at the fifth or
forth fret of the next lower string. Another method uses harmonics
produced between the fifth fret of the lower string and the seventh
fret of the next higher. I have seen this method used by tuning
the harmonics until the beats disappear,
but I found when I tried
to do this, the tuning never came out quite right. It turns out,
that as a consequence of the equal tempered scale
, these harmonics
must be mistuned very slightly for this to work out. I have found
that I can get a suitable tuning by this method, but that the
beat rates required are not always the same.
The need to tune the harmonics produced by each string slightly flat is a result of the difference between the natural harmonic series and the equal tempered scale. Consider the frequency of the first three natural harmonics of each of the guitar strings:
Harmonic: | Fund | 2nd | 3rd | 4th |
Fret: | 12th fret | 7th fret | 5th fret | |
E | 82.407 | 164.814 | 247.221 | 329.628 |
A | 110.000 | 220.000 | 330.000 | 440.000 |
D | 146.832 | 293.665 | 440.497 | 587.330 |
G | 195.998 | 391.995 | 587.993 | 783.991 |
B | 246.942 | 493.883 | 740.825 | 987.767 |
E | 329.628 | 659.255 | 988.883 | 1318.510 |
Notice that the difference between the 3rd harmonic of the A
string and the 4th harmonic of the low E string is .372 Hz.
This means you can tune these strings open, without fretting,
by listening to and adjusting the beat rate of .372 Hz, or about
one beat every 3 seconds. To tune the whole guitar, start by
ringing the 3rd harmonic on the A string (7 th fret) and the
4th harmonic of the low E string (5th fret), and adjusting the
A string sharp to a beat rate of .372 beats per second ( 2.7
seconds per beat). Next, ring the 3rd harmonic on the D string
(7th fret) and the 4th harmonic on the A string, adjusting the
D string sharp to a beat rate of .497 beats per second. Ring
the 3rd harmonic on the G string (7th fret) and the 4th harmonic
of the D string and adjust the G string sharp to a beat rate
of .664 beats per second. The high and low E strings can be tuned
directly by ringing the 4th harmonic of the low E string (5th
fret) and the open high E string and tuning until the beats stop.
Then ring the 3rd harmonic of the high E string (7th fret) and
the 4th harmonic of the B string and adjust the B string flat
to a beat rate of 1.116 beats per second. The guitar should now
sound reasonably well in tune, but on close inspection, it may
not actually be so. This is because beat rates used in the above
procedure were based on ideal harmonics, the partials actually
produced by the string are somewhat different.
A precision strobe tuner can
be used to measure how much the partials
produced vary from the harmonic series. This is done by ringing
each harmonic separately while adjusting the calibration control
to stop the pattern rotation. Then the error is read from the
calibration setting. These measurements must be setup and made
very carefully, since many things can minutely change the fundamental
tuning during the measurements. The neck should be supported
at a point around the 12th fret and the temperature must be stable.
A furnace turning on can vary the string pitch by several cents
or more! The following table shows the results of such a set
of measurements, along with the resultant frequency of each harmonic,
for a new set of Ernie Ball Super Slinky strings on a Gibson Les
Paul Special:
Harmonic: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
Fret: | Open | 12th | 7th | 5th | 9th | 3 1/2 | |
E | Cents | 0 | -1.4 | 0.4 | -0.2 | 1 | 2.6 |
f | 82.407 | 164.681 | 247.278 | 329.589 | 412.273 | 495.184 | |
A | Cents | 0 | -0.2 | 1.4 | 0.8 | 2.6 | 2.2 |
f | 110.000 | 219.975 | 330.267 | 440.203 | 550.827 | 660.839 | |
D | Cents | 0 | 1.6 | 1.8 | 2.4 | 3 | 3.4 |
f | 146.832 | 293.936 | 440.955 | 588.144 | 735.435 | 882.726 | |
G | Cents | 0 | 1 | 1.6 | 2.2 | 3 | 2.4 |
f | 195.998 | 392.222 | 588.537 | 784.988 | 981.688 | 1177.618 | |
B | Cents | 0 | 0.2 | 0.8 | 1 | 0.4 | 0.4 |
f | 246.942 | 493.940 | 741.167 | 988.337 | 1234.994 | 1481.992 | |
E | Cents | 0 | 0 | 0.2 | 0 | -0.2 | -0.4 |
f | 329.628 | 659.255 | 988.997 | 1318.510 | 1647.947 | 1977.308 |
A careful measurement of the partials produced by a set of guitar
strings shows that not only do the partials vary considerably
from the harmonic series, but that how much inharmonicity exists
depends on the type of string, and how worn and dirty it is.
One could use the information from such a set of measurements,
and figure the precise beat rate to use for each set of string
pair harmonics for a perfect tuning. From the table of actual
measurements of guitar strings above, the beat rate required
between the 3rd and 4th harmonics of the B and high E string would
be .66 beats per second, rather than 1.116 beats per second if
the harmonics were ideal. This method would then work until you
changed string types, let the strings rust for a while, or stretched
the living crap out of them. Worn and dirty strings can produce
partials which are off by more than 10 cents from the ideal harmonic
series. The best method for finding the correct beat rates to
use for each sting is probably to tune the six strings perfectly
by some other method and listen for the beat rates actually produced
by each string pair harmonic. This information could then be
used as a basis of a quick tuning check using string harmonics.
But whatever you do, don't try to tune by zero beating the harmonics,
it just won't end up sounding right.